The greatest threat in the Middle East is ‘going to get much worse before it gets better’
Sectarian divisions in the Middle East are only getting worse, and there’s little sign that tensions in the region will abate before they explode into war, experts say.
The Soufan Group, a New-York based strategic security firm, said in a note Friday that the “weaponization of sectarianism,” fueled by the divide between Sunni and Shia Muslims, was the “greatest threat facing the Middle East.”
“In a region beset with chronic and widespread problems, ranging from poor governance, war, violent extremism, and resource scarcity, one threat stands above the rest in terms of potential for destruction and cost in opportunity: the use of sectarianism as a geopolitical weapon,” the firm wrote.
It continued: “Sectarianism encourages extremist rhetoric and violence and serves to distract a populations from economic and social concerns by providing a convenient enemy on which to focus. While the Sunni-Shia divide is as old as Islam, current divisions are driven far more by regional rivalries and political gamesmanship than by religion, though the latter remains a primary factor.”
Ali Khedery served as a special assistant to five US ambassadors, as a senior adviser to three heads of US Central Command, and was the longest continually serving US official in Iraq.
He agreed that tensions between Sunnis and Shiites were getting dangerously worse.
“I think it’s going to get much worse before it gets better,” Khedery told Business Insider.
“It’s just constant escalations,” he continued, later adding, “What I see is constant major escalations by both sides and no de-escalations.”
Saudi Arabia is at the head of a Sunni sphere of influence, while Iran, a Shiite theocracy, is trying to expand its role in the region. Saudi Arabia executed a prominent Shiite cleric last weekend, angering many Iranians. The Sunni kingdom cut off all diplomatic ties with Iran after Iranian protesters ransacked and set fire to the Saudi embassy in Tehran.
US President Barack Obama with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Nayef, center, and Saudi foreign minister Adel Al Jubeir in the Oval Office on May 13.
The US State Department issued a statement saying the execution of the Shiite cleric exacerbated sectarian tensions.
“I was involved in the execution of Saddam Hussein by Malaki in December 2006 and the same exact thing happened,” Khedery said, referring to former Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki.Khedery said these tensions had been getting worse since the US invaded Iraq in 2003. He said the execution of former Iraqi President Saddam Hussein had a similar effect on Shia Muslims.
“Maliki executed him on the holiest day of Islam, which was supposed to be a day of mercy. The Saudis were furious … because the way Saddam was executed with Shias chanting … sparked sectarianism. This has just been an endless tit-for-tat.”
Hussein’s 2006 execution “opened up a more explosive, unprecedented chapter in regional sectarianism,” Khedery said.
But Saudi Arabia’s execution of Nimr al-Nimr, the Shiite cleric, is just the latest example of growing sectarian tensions in the Middle East.
“In the region now you have the majority Sunni Arab world feeling like it’s been under attack by the Persians — and on top of that, perceiving that they are under attack by Shia Persians and Shia Arabs proxies like Lebanese Hezbollah,” Khedery said. “On the other hand, you have from the Shia perspective that they feel they have been repressed for way too long.”
Supporters of the Houthi movement outside the Saudi embassy in Sanaa, Yemen, on Thursday protesting against the execution of al-Nimr.
Both Sunnis and Shiites think they have a right to power and see themselves as coming out on top in a sectarian war. On the Shia side lies Iran, Iraq, Syrian President Bashar Assad, and the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah, Khedery said. On the Sunni side is Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Iraqi Kurdistan, and other Gulf countries.
“There’s basically a sense of manifest destiny and divine right to rule … by both sides,” Khedery said. “What I see is both sides are confident, but at the same time scared, that they’re under a sort of existential threat … We’re in the middle of the fever that still has a long way to burn before the patient comes out standing at the other end.”
And actual military conflict between the two sides might be a real possibility.
“There’s continuing escalation. Both sides are gearing up for direct conflict,” Khedery said. “It’s becoming less ‘Cold War’ and more direct confrontation. Both sides believe they can win, both sides have been gearing up for battle, confident that they can come out on top. And when you have that, you usually have a war. A regional war, a world war … it’s going to be big.”
Other experts, however, have thrown cold water on the idea of an all-out sectarian war in the Middle East.
Marc Lynch, a nonresident senior associate of the Middle East Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, wrote in an op-ed article this week that despite “apocalyptic rhetoric on all sides,” the Saudi execution of the Shiite cleric probably would not change much of the dynamics.
“The implications of the Saudi sectarian escalation for the region’s high politics are likely overstated,” Lynch wrote. “The challenge to Iran and the mobilization of sectarian passions are part of the standard playbook for Riyadh when faced with regional and domestic challenges.”
Still, Lynch cautioned that, with a generation that came of age during the Iraq war and media broadcasting images of sectarian violence daily, the “sectarian game” that is developing is “much more dangerous than in the past.”
He concluded: “It will be far more difficult to de-escalate these sectarian passions than it has been to inflame them.”
IMAGES:
Shi’ite Muslims trying to cross a barricade in front of the Saudi embassy in New Delhi on January 4 during a protest against the execution of cleric Nimr al-Nimr, who was killed along with others in Saudi Arabia. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi
US President Barack Obama with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Nayef, center, and Saudi foreign minister Adel Al Jubeir in the Oval Office on May 13. Kevin Lamarque/Reuters
Supporters of the Houthi movement outside the Saudi embassy in Sanaa, Yemen, on Thursday protesting against the execution of al-Nimr. REUTERS/Khaled Abdullah
For more on this story go to: http://www.businessinsider.com/middle-east-sectarianism-iraq-iran-isis-saudi-arabia-2016-1?utm_source=feedburner&%3Butm_medium=referral&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+businessinsider+%28Business+Insider%29