Experts say Myrie ruling is a turning point for regional integration
From caribbean360
BRIDGETOWN, Barbados, Tuesday November 5, 2013, CMC – Almost a month after the Trinidad-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) ruled that Barbados had breached the rights of a Jamaican national when she sought entry into the country in 2011, regional stakeholders say the judgment represents a turning point for the regional integration movement.
The CCJ was established in 2001 to replace the London-based Privy Council as the region’s final court, but while many Caribbean Community (CARICOM) countries are signatories to its original jurisdiction, only Barbados, Guyana and Belize are signatories to the appellate jurisdiction of the court that also serves as an international tribunal interpreting the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas that governs the integration movement.
At a panel discussion at the Cave Hill campus of the University of the West Indies earlier this week, panellists examined the implications of the CCJ ruling in the Shanique Myrie case in which Barbados was also ordered to pay BDS$75,000 (one BDS dollar = US$0.50 cents) in compensation.
Myrie, who had been granted leave by the CCJ to file the action, alleged that when she travelled to Barbados on March 14, 2011 she was discriminated against because of her nationality, subjected to a body cavity search, detained overnight in a cell and deported to Jamaica the following day.
Myrie also claimed that she was subjected to derogatory remarks by a Barbadian Immigration officer and asked the CCJ to determine the minimum standard of treatment applicable to CARICOM citizens moving around the region.
Barbados Attorney General Adriel Brathwaite said that while the introduction of free movement within CARICOM though noble, it was not properly thought out.
Highlighting Barbados’s concerns, he said there were not enough structures in place to ensure free movement work and if the region doesn’t get it right, there will be chaos.
“We’re faced with a situation where we are concerned about whether or not we have the capacity not only to provide housing for all of our people but for those of us, those people from the region who we would love to come to live with us.
“But we can’t invite people to come and live with us and then we have six and eight people living in a room, sharing one bathroom etc., (these) kind of stories you hear from time to time.
“We have the whole issue of education. We, to the best of my knowledge are about three secondary schools behind where we would like to be and probably three or four junior schools from where we would like to be. If we want to invite our brothers and sisters we want to ensure that they also have access to education,” he said.
Brathwaite insisted there’s nothing earth shattering about the Myrie judgement and that Bridgetown has already made moves to re-train its border personnel in keeping with the CCJ ruling.
But he stressed that all member states must follow suit to make free movement a reality.
“What we were doing is that we were granting three months initial and then if you want an extension come back and give us a chance so we can get an idea in terms of what you are doing, what you are up to and if you needed the additional three months then they will give you the additional three months.
“All it means now from a particular perspective is that you want the six months and rather than having the mechanism where you need to come back to us, if we think there are issues we will go to you. It means that we will have to have some additional bodies on the ground immigration-wise but that’s what happens in most countries.
“So that’s why I said it is really not a major issue. What might be the major issue would be the fact that we really have to change psyche of many Immigration Officers across the region. I have been in St Kitts going into Nevis and been asked how come I am going into Nevis so often? I have been asked that. So it is not a case where it only happens in Barbados,” he added.
But Dean at the UWI Faculty of Law, Dr David Berry, believes it is important Caribbean people are educated about their rights under the Treaty of Chaguaramas. He said the treaty does not in fact grant freedom of movement.
“It grants freedom of movement in Article 46 to CARICOM Skilled Nationals, certain categories of persons. So what the revised treaty does have is another provision which says towards the goal of free movement we will try to do these things.
“So Article 45 talks about a goal of free movement and Article 46 is of one instance of free movement. So the revised treaty itself, and this was argued before the court, does not give a full blown right of freedom of movement.”
He said the regional leaders at their conference in 2007 created in a sense a right of free movement. “They created an automatic right to enter and stay for six months subject to sufficiency of funds…you will not become a burden on the public purse and that you are not undesirable. So those are the two criteria.”
But Dr Tennyson Joseph, the head of the Department of Government, Sociology and Social Work at the university said the Myrie ruling has forced the region to rethink the concept of sovereignty.
He said the region’s current economic troubles have also led some governments to look inward, moving away from the vision of deeper integration articulated by the framers of the “Time for Action” report who laid the foundation for strengthening of CARICOM and the integration movement.
“Whether or not the rationale that they identified which forced them to ask for a revised treaty, has either deepened or diminished, I would say that the challenges are greater. But because the challenges are greater one of the tendencies is for us to become regionalist instead of xenophobic.
“Instead of redefining sovereignty towards more regional framework, we turn inwards. Hitler faced a similar issue in his time in the First World War period, where he was facing an economic crisis and you know which choice that he took.
“Sovereignty is malleable, that the nation of citizenship is malleable. Globalization has raised new questions about what is a citizen. What is a state and what sovereignty,” Joseph added.
Another academic, Orlando Marville, the coordinator, Law, Governance and Society at the UWI said political leaders must do more to build a community.
He said ordinary citizens were making integration a lived reality and it’s time for the political directorate to speed up the process.
“Very often ordinary people sometimes appreciate the community that we have more than the political agents. We sometimes make promises or agree to things that they know that they are not going to do, until come back to bite them.
“We have to have the sort of commonness that exist for instance among our musicians. I have been in Suriname and heard Surinamese sing bits of songs from Kross Fyah (in Barbados). Alison Hinds sings a song from Suriname as part of her thing and these musicians all believe in our community.
“The question for me is does the Myrie case help us strengthen our understanding of community or pushes away,” he asked.
PHOTO: Dean at the UWI faculty of law believes it is important for Caribbean people to be educated about their rights under the Treaty of Chaguaramas. (File photo)
For more on this story go to:
Related story:
B’dos gov’t retrains immigration personnel after CCJ ruling – AG
From Go-Jamaica
The Barbadian Government has announced that it has already taken steps to re-train its immigration and border personnel in keeping with the landmark ruling in the Shanique Myrie case.
And the country’s attorney general, Adriel Brathwaite, says other CARICOM member states must follow suit to ensure that the free movement of Caribbean nationals across the region becomes a reality.
Brathwaite’s comments come nearly a month after the Caribbean Court of Justice ruled that Barbados had breached Myrie’s right when she sought entry into that country in 2011.
In addition to the BDS$75,000 awarded to Myrie, the court also established a number of benchmark treatments it says CARICOM nationals should enjoy when they travel throughout the region.
Speaking during a panel discussion in Barbados last week, Brathwaite cautioned that the introduction of free movement throughout the Caribbean is a noble concept that has not been properly thought out.
Pointing to some of the challenges facing regional governments, he says there are not enough structures to support the free movement of CARICOM nationals and warns that this could cause chaos.
For more on this story go to:
http://go-jamaica.com/news/read_article.php?id=49043
See related iNews Cayman stories:
Published October 8 2013 “Myrie case sets framework for CARICOM travel” at: http://www.ieyenews.com/wordpress/myrie-case-sets-framework-for-caricom-travel/
Published October 30 2013 “Danger of mixed signals” at: http://www.ieyenews.com/wordpress/danger-of-mixed-signals/
